1

Homemade Cake

2

Fancy Jam/Jelly

3

Small jar of dark-colored honey

4

Freshly-baked cookies

5

Bag of hard candies

6

Fancy chef salts

7

Bottle of wine (cheap)

8

Bottle of wine (expensive)

9

Tin of loose leaf tea

10

Jar of pickles

11

Fruit basket

12

Box of chocolate

13

Tin of mints

14

Bottle of olive oil

15

Hot sauce

16

Freshly caught fish

17

Basket of fresh produce

18

Homebrewed Beer

19

Basket of truffles

20

Bag of Whole Bean Coffee

21

Homemade Butter

22

Matcha with whisk and cup

23

Strange-flavored soda

24

Farm fresh eggs in many colors

25

Freshly baked bread

26

Day-old bread

27

Bag of roasted nuts

28

Pink box of donuts

29

Assortment of fresh herbs

30

Homemade dinner

31

Hot apple cider

32

Assortment of dried bugs

33

Wheel of cheese

34

Citrus Fruit

35

Fruitcake

36

Dried mushrooms

37

Chocolate fudge

38

Margarita Mix

39

Rose water

40

Vanilla extract

41

Chocolate coins

42

Vegetable spread

43

Smoked paprika

44

Jar of pesto

45

Bag of dried pasta

46

Smoked fish

47

Marzipan candy

48

Honeycomb

49

Pancake mix

50

Bag of short-grain rice

51

Hand-knitted scarf

52

Woolen socks

53

Jeweled Earrings

54

Crystal necklace (stone of your choice)

55

Comfortable slippers

56

Sturdy work boots

57

Amulet

58

Friendship bracelet

59

Simple gold ring

60

Pajama pants

61

Silly hat

62

Practical Hat

63

Warm hat

64

Decorative bobby pins / hair clips

65

Bath robe / dressing gown

66

Mittens

67

Shawl made in neighboring town

68

Round colored sunglasses

69

Funny-shaped sunglasses

70

Billowing cloak

71

Quilted jacket with sparkling lining

72

Frilly apron

73

Hair bow

74

Glass eye

75

Bejeweled eye patch

76

Iridescent body piercing(s)

77

Second-hand jacket

78

Oversized belt buckle

79

Galoshes

80

Simple white mask

81

Cloth medical mask

82

Masquerade mask

83

Red cape

84

Cloak that is invisible (does not make wearer invisible)

85

Wizard's robes

86

Hand-knit sweater

87

School uniform

88

Clogs

89

Silly wig

90

Fancy wig

91

Jewelry made of real teeth

92

Dance outfit

93

Bocci ball set

94

Traditional costume

95

Beaded glasses chain

96

Wallet chain

97

Cat ears

98

Mittens that look like paws

99

Tiara / crown

100

Leather satchel

101

Handmade Plush Animal (High Quality)

102

Handmade Plush Animal (Low Quality, but still cute)

103

Quilt made from old shirts

104

Music box that plays a haunting melody

105

Letter opener that looks like a fancy dagger

106

Instant Camera with film

107

Set of paints with quality brushes

108

Crystal statuette of a whale

109

Nautilus shell

110

Bouquet of flowers

111

Faberge egg

112

Salt and pepper shakers that look like pigs

113

Soup tureen that looks like a chicken

114

Candle (smells good)

115

Candle (smells...not good)

116

Handmade soap

117

Book (Villager's favorite)

118

Book (Your favorite)

119

Board game

120

Gardening tools

121

Cookbook

122

Woven basket

123

Second-hand teapot

124

Puzzle box

125

Bath salts

126

Love letter

127

Houseplant

128

Knitting / Crochet supplies

129

Quality Chef knife

130

Angel figure

131

Bag of seeds (flower)

132

Bag of seeds (produce)

133

Portrait of you (high quality)

134

Portrait of you (low quality)

135

Vibrant feathers

136

A kiss 😳

137

A song

138

New tool

139

Pouch of coins from around the world

140

Lantern

141

Shaped cookie cutters

142

Scrapbook of your recent memories

143

Terracotta pot

144

Second-hand typewriter

145

Worry stone

146

Letter from deceased relative

147

Contact info (phone number, etc)

148

Makeup kit

149

Book of poems

150

Perfume

151

Small pouch that makes a fart sound when sat upon

152

Pot of invisible ink

153

Plastic blow-up hammer

154

Foam sword

155

Small stone with hole in the middle

156

Rose that never wilts

157

Candle that always stays lit

158

Book of puns

159

Spoon that makes everything its stirs sweeter

160

Tome with a purple leather cover and silver detailing

161

Globe of the world that shows the weather

162

Karaoke Microphone

163

Waffle maker that makes heart-shaped waffles

164

LGBTQ+ Pride Pins (your choice)

165

Heart of a Shooting Star

166

Tarot Deck

167

Clown Doll that... might be haunted

168

Cat statuette that occasionally meows

169

Pen with multiple colors

170

Bocce ball set

171

Chess set

172

Full-size gold statue of the mayor

173

Sticky hand

174

Broken instrument

175

Slime

176

Good luck charm

177

Jar of loose buttons

178

Balloon animal kit

179

Terracotta foot scrubbers

180

Blanket with sleeves

181

Tomato pin cushion

182

Pet fish

183

Unicycle

184

Jar of fairy dust (real)

185

Jar of fairy dust (fake)

186

Green popcorn

187

Hardcover volume of popular free indie ttrpg

188

Cup that maintains temperature of liquid inside (hot or cold)

189

Handheld digital pet game

190

Old portrait of unknown person that blinks occasionally

191

Skeleton key that can open any door

192

Angel feather

193

Rock with googly eyes

194

Pine cone

195

Jar that can not be opened

196

Trashy and fun romance novel

197

Vial of water from magic stream

198

Single crystal shoe

199

Jeweled skull

200

Slime

201

A bag of dice

202

A binder full of trading cards

203

A boxful of chicken nuggets

204

A clown nose

205

A copy of Starforged

206

A creepy doll

207

A four leaf clover

208

A large energy drink

209

A loaf of freshly baked bread

210

A lock of hair

211

A mask

212

A pacifier

213

A pair of clown shoes

214

A pair of comfy slippers

215

A piggy bank (half full)

216

A potoo puppet

217

A pressed flower in an envelope

218

A Pride Flag

219

A pride flag pin

220

A religious book

221

A small sack full of seeds

222

A thermos of soup

223

A tiara / crown

224

A walking cane/stick

225

A wand

226

A warm pair of mittens

227

A wonderful towel

228

An endearing garden gnome

229

An old Bugnet

230

An old Fishing Rod

231

An old shirt that's full of memories

232

An old, time-worn book

233

Ball of Yarn

234

Beetle in a jar

235

Binoculars

236

Book of family recipes

237

Book of songs

238

Broken Locket

239

Camera

240

Contacts pocketbook full of names

241

Crystal ball

242

Deck of Tarot Cards

243

Expensive Jewelry

244

Extra Boot

245

Extra pair of glasses

246

Extra pair of undies

247

Extra thick jacket/coat

248

Family photo album

249

Fidget Toy

250

Fingerless leather gloves with rhinestones

251

First Aid Kit

252

Friendship bracelet

253

Hand Mirror

254

Handful of buttons

255

Homemade scarf

256

Letter not addressed to you

257

Lighter

258

Mountain Bicycle

259

Music Box

260

Musical Instrument

261

Old keys

262

Old Newspaper of the day when it happened

263

Old sketchbook full of drawings

264

Origami Crane

265

Pair of spare socks/leggings

266

Pins to put on your shirt or hat

267

Portable Radio

268

Public Transport Pass (Useless)

269

Purse filled with various coins

270

Really fancy shoelaces

271

Rubber Chicken

272

Rubber Duck

273

Rusty Old Tool

274

Sewing Kit

275

Someone else's handwritten diary

276

Sports Trophy and Medals

277

Textbook on another language

278

The Coffee Cup you got from Work

279

The tooth of a mysterious creature

280

Their favorite hat

281

Thread and Needle

282

Time-worn treasure map

283

Tomato-shaped Kitchen Timer

284

Typewriter

285

Umbrella

286

Wedding Ring

287

Worn Out picture of a loved one

288

Writer's Pen

289

Your childhood plush

290

Your dad's folding knife

291

Your favorite board game

292

Your favorite hat

293

Your novel manuscript

294

Your old notebook of poetry

295

Your pair of roller skates

296

Your trusty family pet

297

Your trusty raincoat

298

Your Very Own Rat